Ardnahoe 6 anni single cask Flickenschild, Ardbeg Eureka e Valinch David Hope comprati all'asta

Many of the bottles that come up at online auctions can also be found at retail: usually at least one or two online shops stock them, bar a few exceptions. At auction they often cost a lot less, but on top of the hammer price you have to add commission, shipping and taxes, depending on the auction house and the month. And above all, you have to wait for “that” bottle to come up for auction. Some turn up often in auctions with plenty of lots. For others you have to wait months, if not years.

Either way, for the classic core range bottles it usually isn’t worth it, whereas for old editions and limited releases it is. I know a thing or two about it: I’ve been buying at auction for years, mostly on whiskyauction.com, Whisky Auctioneer and Whisky Auktion Berlin, and by now I’ve picked up a few dozen bottles there.

The wait

The flip side, as I said, is the wait. You can’t pick up a bottle at auction whenever you feel like it: you have to wait for someone to put it up for sale, remember when the auction ends (yes, that too), place your bid, decide whether to go higher if someone outbids you, and wait for the close. Or bid and go to bed… because some end late, and wake up to find your card charged. In a shop the same bottle might cost up to twice as much, but you buy it there and then; at auction, right up to the end, you don’t know if you’ll win.

Know the bottle before you bid

On whiskyauction.com I have ended up buying bottles more or less at random. At least a couple of times… mostly just back from Islay, completely hooked. On one of those occasions I won two Caol Ilas with no age statement, knocked down at €90 each. The order also included several other bottles, so the shipping was spread across all of them and each of the two worked out at around a hundred euros.

I’ve seen the same bottle on a couple of sites at around €180. The thing is, that Caol Ila is nothing special, and I’d bought two. I did save money, but it wasn’t worth it.

Mistakes like this one gave me a rule I still follow: I don’t bid on a bottle I don’t know. If I haven’t got a feel for a whisky, because I don’t know the distillery well or because I haven’t tasted comparable editions, I ignore it even if I think it’ll go for “not much”. I go into an auction already knowing which bottle I’m after and how much I’m prepared to spend, not to browse.

Of course, it’s easy to say that now, given some of the stuff I’ve bought at auction completely at random.

Price history

Once you’ve picked the bottle, it’s absolutely crucial to know what it fetched at previous auctions. I use DramX, which covers around 30 auction houses and 4.8 million lots sold, and it’s very handy for checking a bottle’s auction values. Anyone who wants to sign up can use the code torbati, which gives 50% off the first month (I don’t earn anything from it anyway).

Compared with other tools, DramX clearly shows both the hammer price and what the winning bidder paid, and the gap between the two figures varies from one auction house to the next. I check it every time I’ve got my eye on a bottle. Take the Ardbeg Eureka, which I bought from Whisky Auktion Berlin in March 2026: over the last twelve months it averaged a hammer price of £86 there and £97 actually paid; at Whisky Auctioneer it was £74 and £84, at European Whisky Auctions £67 and £73.

In July 2026, on Whisky.Auction, which is a different house from whiskyauction.com despite the name, two 75cl Laphroaig 10 pre-Royal Warrant bottles went under the hammer at £650 for the 43% one and £220 for the 40% one. Litre bottles sold for between £500 and £650, the 70cl bottles from the nineties for between £150 and £230. Mine is a nineties 70cl, bought for £190 in 2024. A fair price.

With single casks you can end up with nothing to compare against. For example, I recently picked up an Ardnahoe 6 Year Old “Flickenschild” (a shop in Germany, I think), and the only auction sale on record is mine: €72. Still a bargain for an Ardnahoe single cask that sold out quickly.

From hammer price to final bill

On whiskyauction.com sales are between private individuals and the house takes care of the logistics. On top of the hammer price there’s a 10% service fee, €3 per bottle, shipping and insurance. In October 2024 four bottles knocked down for €693 cost me €816.30 in total, 17.8% more. A single €105 bottle, in February 2025, came to €139.50, or 32.9% more, because shipping was €21 for one bottle against €32 for four.

At Whisky Auktion Berlin the buyer’s premium is 15%, plus €15 for packing and €29 for DHL shipping on three bottles. In March 2026, on €438 of winning bids, I spent €547.70, a quarter more.

The biggest jump over the hammer price I’ve had was on Whisky Auctioneer’s UK lots, because of the EU VAT that comes on a second invoice after the order. I won the Country Life, a 1986 Bruichladdich 15 Year Old from cask 356, for £170 in October 2024. With buyer’s premium, shipping and insurance it came to £239.99; then another £35.70 of VAT turned up, for a total of £275.69, 62.2% above the hammer price. For me, though, it had sentimental value: I couldn’t let it slip.

Where the lot is held matters too. On Whisky Auctioneer in February and May 2026, the Caol Ila 15 Flora and Fauna sold for £80-85 when the lot was already in the European Union, while UK lots went for £130 (£150 with the wooden box). Mine was a UK lot, bought for £130 in November 2024, and VAT came on top.

Catawiki and the Lagavulin Sweet Peat

I haven’t bought anything on Catawiki so far. The way I see it, it’s heavily geared towards beginners, almost taking advantage of their inexperience. The auctions are presented as curated by experts, yet the selections strike me as fairly random and they repeat a lot. Instead of a few major auctions, scheduled and well spaced out, there’s an endless run of short auctions handed to this or that curator, and I can’t see the added value. At the end of the day, what people care about is the bottles on offer.

That’s where the Lagavulin Sweet Peat turned up once, the 11 Year Old, which wasn’t available in Italy. I was tempted, but I decided to wait for it to reach the retailers and let it go. Since then it has vanished completely, from auctions and from the normal retail channels alike. I’ll wait, like a good auction regular.

What's your favourite Islay distillery?

Francesco De Val

Peated whisky enthusiast who has visited Islay three years in a row.

You may also like...

🗺 Islay Map